Recent mhra guidance for the surveillance of people with metal on metal hip replacements are onerous, costly, and insufficiently evidence based, argue gulraj matharu and colleagues metal on metal hips were commonly used in young active patients with arthritis, with about 1. On 26 may 2017, the new eu medical devices regulation mdr and in vitro diagnostics regulation ivdr entered into force. The alert is directed at healthcare providers who monitor patients with all metal hip replacement implants. Original medical device alert by uk mhra 2017 available here. In 2017, the medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra published updated guidelines on monitoring patients with all types of metal on metal hip implants. Concerns about metal on metal implants were also raised two weeks ago when the uks medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra said.
Updated information published by the mhra in respect of metal. As knowledge of the performance and outcomes of hip arthroplasty with metalonmetal bearings increases, the guest commentaries below and here revisit. The updated advice features in a new mhra medical device alert issued to clinicians managing patients with metal on metal hip implants, and aims to minimise the risk of such individuals requiring further surgery to correct complications. On 29 june 2017, the mhra published updated followup recommendations for all patients with metal on metal hip replacements. Please use one of the following formats to cite this article in your essay, paper or report. It is an update to a previous medical device alert continue reading. There is conflicting evidence on whether there is a correlation between. What flame colour did you observe when the metal burnt.
Adverse reaction to metal debris after recapm2amagnum largediameterhead metalonmetal total hip arthroplasty article pdf available in acta orthopaedica 846 october 20 with 145 reads. Hip implants have provided lifechanging treatment, reducing pain and improving the mobility and independence of patients. Mhra publishes updated guidance on metal on metal hip implants posted. Biomet is committed to ongoing postmarket surveillance of its products, including its metal on metal mom hip devices. The regulation and governance of medical devices in. Safety information metal on metal hip implants timeline. Mhra is updating advice provided in mda2012036, to assist the early detection of soft tissue reactions in patients implanted with metal on metal mom hip replacements mda2017018. You will be aware that the mhra medical and healthcare related devices agency has been investigating the incidence of adverse events associated with metal on metal. Problem action the mhra has received reports of revisions of mom hip replacements involving soft tissue reactions. Sws lay airfields, erect towers, assemble pontoon causeways, reinforce concrete, and erect buildings. Chapter 1 introduction to types and identification of metal. The correlation of serum metal ions with functional outcome scores at threetosix years following large head metal on metal hip arthroplasty. Updated guidelines to monitor metal on metal devices by uk. Jul 11, 2017 updated information published by the mhra in respect of metal on metal hip replacements.
Differential distribution of cobalt, chromium, and nickel. Mhra investigation over toxic hip replacements channel. The orientation of the crystal within each grain is generally different from the orientation in adjacent grains. Followup for patients with metalonmetal hip replacements. Failure rates of stemmed metal on metal hip replacements. Methods periprosthetic soft tissues biopsied at time of revision from failed mom hip arthroplasties from january 2007 to march 2011 were. Archived all mhra issues updated information and advice for the followups of patients implanted with metal on metal mom hip replacements. Deborah cohen examines the evidence of risk from metal on metal hips, the manufacturers inadequate response, and how the regulatory bodies failed to give doctors and patients the.
Pdf adverse reaction to metal debris after recapm2amagnum. Mhra publishes updated guidance on metalonmetal hip implants. Introduction to types and identification of metal topics 1. Screening standards needed for blood metal ion concentrations.
All patients with metal on metal hip implants are advised to have blood tests and either plain radiographs or scans, under new guidance by the medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra. Mhra dear dr hudson, i am writing to you regarding the attached correspondence i have received which raises concerns over the medicines and healthcare products regulations agency mhra and its devices expert advisory committee, with specific reference to metalonmetal mom hip replacements. Updated information published by the mhra in respect of. Clinical study the correlation of serum metal ions with. Jun 12, 2012 the medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra has issued advice to surgeons to stop using a particular combination of metal on metal total hip replacements because it has a high revision rate compared with other implants. The uks medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra on thursday issued an alert to healthcare professionals with updated recommendations for longterm followup for patients with metal on metal hip replacements. Important information on metalonmetal hips zimmer biomet. It also looks towards the future of medical device. If you dont allow cookies, you may not be able to use certain features of the web site such as personalized content. The medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra uk has called for longerterm monitoring of all patients fitted with metal on metal hip implants, as a precautionary measure, in an. The mhra has played a prominent leadership role in the development and management of the regulatory system in the eu and beyond. The metal ion levels of either blood chromium or cobalt exceeded the action level of 7 ppb proposed in the medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra, uk guidelines in.
These blood ion level tests, like all medical tests, need to be sensitive and specific. Reference alert title originated by issue date status. Medsafe has compiled a detailed timeline beginning with the release of the depuy asr resurfacing hip system, through to the august 2010 recall action hazard alert, and information issued by other medical device regulators since then. All of the patients had increased blood metal ion levels with a significant variation between the patients. Executive summary it is estimated that at least 500,000 current generation metal on metal mom hip replacements have been implanted worldwide over the last 15 years with excellent results from experienced surgeons. Predicting high blood metal ion concentrations following. Metal on metal hip replacement and hip resurfacing. The medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra said on tuesday that around 49,000 uk patients with largehead hip implants out of 65,000 with all metal.
The mhra have issued a statement on depuys metal on metal hip implants, while the telegraph newspaper reports concerns that the devices could be more dangerous than previously thought on monday 30th january 2012, an mhra spokesman said, on the evidence currently available the majority of patients implanted with metal on metal hip replacements are at low risk of developing. Mhras guide to the new eu medical devices regulations. Success has encouraged manufacturers to innovate and amend designs, engendering patient hopes in these devices. This mismatch between grains is accommodated by grain boundaries, which are thin disordered regions. The new guidance expands the pool of patients who may be at risk of bone or muscle damage from their metal on metal hip replacements. In response to ongoing monitoring of the performance of metal on metal mom hip joint articulations the mhra published an updated medical device alert on. Metal artefact reduction mar mri is now widely considered to be the standard for imaging metal on metal mom hip implants. The medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra has issued advice to surgeons to stop using a particular combination of metal on metal total hip replacements because it has a high revision rate compared with other implants. Grain size is an important factor in the mechanical strength of metals. In the seabees, the steelworker sw rating is recognized as the resident expert on the use of metal. The nature of aseptic lymphocytic vasculitis associated lesion alval is investigated. Metalonmetal mom hip replacements updated advice with.
The mhra was the first regulatory agency in the world to issue advice to clinicians about metalonmetal hip implants in april 2010 and we, in combination with our expert advisory group, are continuing to closely monitor all the latest evidence about these devices. By use of data from the national joint registry of england and wales, smith and colleagues were able to assess more than 400 000 primary hipreplacement procedures, of which 31 171 employed stemmed metal on metal prostheses that were commonly used between 2003 and 2011. Pdf 601 metalonmetal total hip replacements with 36mm. All metal on metal mom hip replacements problem action the mhra is issuing updated information and advice about the management and monitoring of patients implanted with metal on metal mom hip replacements. This document presents a process to assess and control elemental impurities in the drug product using the principles of risk management as described in ich q9. Mhra dear dr hudson, i am writing to you regarding the attached correspondence i have received which raises concerns over the medicines and healthcare products regulations agency mhra and its devices expert advisory committee, with specific reference to metal on metal mom hip replacements.
Pdf serial magnetic resonance imaging of metalonmetal. This process provides a platform for developing a riskbased control strategy to limit elemental impurities in the drug product. Jan 30, 2012 the article also claims that advisers to the mhra have decided that further advice should be issued due to concerns that the devices could cause systemic toxicity in the body. As reported on bbc on february 28th 2012, the british medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra advised that patients who have undergone large head metal on metal hip replacements should be monitored annually for life. Sws lay airfields, erect towers, assemble pontoon causeways, reinforce. All patients with metalonmetal hip implants should. The regulation of medical devices in scotland is complex and often poorly understood. These reactions may be associated with unexplained hip pain. Levels of armd remain low despite a comprehensive screening program. All patients with metalonmetal hip implants should undergo. New mhra guidance on nonmedical devices bioslice blog. They also use their expertise to fabricate all types of metal objects, repair metal items, and resurface worn machinery parts. Consistent with this commitment and to act appropriately and responsibly in the interest of patient welfare, biomet has been closely monitoring the available data regarding its mom hip devices. The agency was the first in the world to flag up problems with metal on metal hip replacements and to issue guidance on management.
It is of note that although in the mrha april 2012 guidance it is stated that the majority of patients implanted with metal on metal hip replacements have well functioning hips and are at low risk of developing serious problems, dr susanne ludgate, clinical director of the mhra has said that patients with metal on metal hip replacements should. The medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra uk has called for longerterm monitoring of all patients fitted with metal on metal hip implants, as a precautionary measure, in an update to its original guidance issued in 2012. There have been reports in the print media in recent weeks about soft tissue problems developing in patients with metal on metal mom hip resurfacings and hip replacements. The purpose of this paper is to determine the prevalence of metal on metal mom total hip replacement thr in european registries, to assess the incidence of revision surgery and to describe the national followup guidelines for patients with mom thr including resurfacings. There have been reports in the print media in recent weeks about soft tissue problems developing in patients with metalonmetal mom hip resurfacings and hip replacements. Sep 10, 2015 most metal objects contain large numbers of individual grains. The regulation and governance of medical devices in scotland.
Updated guidelines to monitor metal on metal devices by uks. More than 30,000 british patients have received metal on metal hip replacements that could be causing systemic toxicity in the. Precaution, governance and the failure of medical implants. You will be aware that the mhra medical and healthcare related devices agency has been investigating the incidence of adverse events associated with metal on metal mom hips. Metal sensitivity as a cause of groin pain in metal on metal hip resurfacing. Jun 29, 2018 the regulation of medical devices in scotland is complex and often poorly understood.
Metal on metal implants used for hip resurfacing or replacement are at the epicentre of the controversy because weaknesses in regulatory systems for medical devices have been exposed. The lancet, volume 380, issue 9837, failure rates high in all metal hip implants, not just depuy september 23, 2014. Medsafe has compiled a detailed timeline beginning with the release of the depuy asr resurfacing hip system, through to the august 2010 recall action hazard alert, and information. The failure rate of the articular surface replacement metal on metal hip system, implanted almost 100,000. The mhra has also advised surgeons to closely monitor patients with this combination of implants. Checkups are a precautionary measure to reduce the small risk of complications and monitor patients who have had the devices implanted for a long time. Metal on metal hip replacement and hip resurfacing arthroplasty.
Report of the eag on soft tissue reactions associated with. Sensitive means that the test will detect with known probability whether there is a problem. Boabhs statement on metal on metal hip implants update. News mhra issues statement on metalonmetal hip implants. Metalonmetal hip replacements high failure rate bbc news.
This is a planned update as the mhra has said all along that it would issue new updated guidance as more information and. On 12 october 2018, the mhra issued guidance for products without an intended medical purpose annex xvi under the new medical device regulation eu 2017745 providing guidance on the expansion of scope of the medical devices regime to include certain products which had been previously unregulated at eu level article 12 of the medical devices regulation mdr, in force from 25 may. Identifying and diagnosing patients with metal hypersensitivity. Aim to describe the histopathology of localised adverse reactions to metal debris armd seen in association with failed metal on metal mom hip arthroplasties. Mhra updates recommendations for metalonmetal hip replacements june 30, 2017 the uks medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency has updated its followup recommendations for metalonmetal hip replacements. Uk quality assurance of blood cobalt and chromium after hip implants article pdf available in bmj online 344jun12 2. What is appropriate surveillance for metalonmetal hip. Mhra updates alert on metalonmetal hip implants raps. Metalonmetal hip replacements who owns your implant. Read our roundup of metalonmetal hip resurfacings here. The british orthopaedic association boa and british hip society bhs welcome the update issued by the medicine and healthcare devices regulatory authority mhra.
This chapter introduces three broad aspects of metals in medicine. Regulatory agency mhra issued alert on most mom bearings suggesting continued surveillance of such device with regular clinical outcome, metal. On february 28, 2012, the medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra in the uk issued an updated medical device alert regarding management of patients with metal on metal hip replacement devices. Metalonmetal failuresin science, regulation, and policy. Mhra, researchers warn of metalonmetal hip implant risks. In recent years, there has been considerable public concern over the safety of some medical devices and an increase in the number of medical devices subject to recall. Dec 17, 2014 archived all mhra issues updated information and advice for the followups of patients implanted with metal on metal mom hip replacements. Ich q3d elemental impurities european medicines agency.
Specific means that if the test is positive, then the problem is with known probability metal. In response to on going monitoring of the performance of metal on metal mom hip joint articulations the mhra published an updated medical device alert on 29 june 2017 in respect of all mom hip replacements. This briefing looks at the regulation and governance of medical devices in scotland. In order to aid preparations for the provisions taking effect, the medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra has published materials to help manufacturers understand the new requirements, and in particular, has published an introductory. The medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra has. Arrange the metals in the decreasing order of their reactivity. This is reassuring given the cohort tested was considered atrisk of armd all symptomatic patients and. The agency was the first in the world to flag up problems with metalonmetal hip replacements and to issue guidance on management. The medicines and healthcare products regulatory agency mhra has issued updated guidance for healthcare professionals who manage patients implanted with metal on metal hip replacements. News new mhra alert for metalonmetal hip replacements.
Jun 29, 2017 mhra is updating advice provided in mda2012036, to assist the early detection of soft tissue reactions in patients implanted with metal on metal mom hip replacements mda2017018. We have been monitoring the issues surrounding metal on metal bearing hips for some time. Mar 01, 2012 please use one of the following formats to cite this article in your essay, paper or report. Dashed horizontal line represents the mhra threshold for co 120 nmoll. The inflammatory phenotype in failed metalonmetal hip. A practical guide to the use and management of modern hip resurfacings.
1161 871 494 1494 1167 1267 1325 706 878 529 690 510 209 595 29 1155 889 1043 980 309 1030 673 918 290 1396 125 993 321 149 124 1350 500 1410 833 632 310 203 314 656 661 925 166 496 1117 587